Podcast episode
We Analyzed 85 Million Cold Emails: This is How You GUARANTEE Replies | Sell Playbook
30 Minutes to President's Club22 Jul 202544 min
Description
Huge Announcement đ Our next course is here: The Reply Method for Double Digit Replies Learn more + get free toolkits here: https://www.30mpc.com/course/cold-email-course What you need to know: A great cold email system gets you more replies, from better prospects, in less time â and it works even when you're not perfect. Thatâs what this course teaches: how to write cold emails that feel personal, without spending hours customizing. How to craft offers that actually get responses. How to sequence, follow up, and stand out in crowded inboxes. Teams that master this skill consistently book more meetings than teams that donât â no matter the industry. If you donât have a system, cold email becomes a grind with diminishing returns. If you do, it becomes your most consistent pipeline lever. â We analyzed 85 million cold emails with Gong to find what actually gets replies in 2025. In this episode, Nick and Jason break down the exact cold email structure, CTAs, and personalization tactics top reps are using to book more meetings. đď¸ ACTIONABLE TAKEAWAYS: Use The Reply Method framework: 4-sentence emails under 100 words outperform longer messagesâmake it skimmable, mobile-first, and frictionless to reply. Avoid pitch language: Buzzwords and product-first copy reduce replies by up to 57%. Lead with problems your buyer already cares about, then layer in social proof. Personalize to the company or activity: Personalization = 5x replies, but not all types are equalâcompany and activity-based personalization outperform personal trivia. Offer something valuable in your CTA: Replace âAre you free?â with a compelling offerâbenchmarking, expert insights, or 1:1 value that justifies a meeting even if they donât buy. RESOURCES DISCUSSED ChatGPT Prompts + Cold Email Course $50 off (discount auto applied at checkout) Join our weekly newsletter Things you can steal Save $50 on any 30MPC course with code âPODCASTâ Free Sales Templates, Scripts and Guides 30MPC Training: 30mpc.com/training
Show moreShow less
Listen
Loading the recording
This recording could not be loaded.Open the audio file
Quoted on this wiki
Every place a page here uses this source, in the order the words come in it.
is that people buy emotionally, and then they justify logically. And so in our sale, we have to get them bought in emotionally before we show ROI language. When we're selling our sponsorships, we're not leading with ROI. Even though that matters to the marketing leaders we're selling to, we're starting by getting them bought in on the emotional piece of the sale, “And so leading with that in a cold email, it's just stagnant, stale, and it feels like work where I'm calculating the ROI of a solution I didn't even ask to hear about.” So all of that stuff is going to hurt your response rate. The thing that surprised me the most actually was the AI piece. I knew that talking about buzzwords was bad, platform I knew was bad, ROI, no, you're generally not supposed to do that.
We try to shift the buyer's priorities and say, you know what? You're over in your world over here. Come into my world, dude. It's really freaking awesome. You should care a lot about this. That doesn't work when you do outbound. We have to start in their world and we have to give them priority-based language. “We have to show them it's for them. It's for their industry. It's connected to something that they care about.” When you give your solution first and you don't give context through that problem, it's just going to be a complete mess. It's the same. I met my wife on Tinder, Sarah. It's no different than just the first message saying, here's my stats, dude. Here's my credit score.
You know, so if you sell to CPG brands and let's say you help them with e-comm or something like that. I mean, like you could say, instead of reaching out to all supplement companies, you could focus on fitness supplement companies. You could focus on energy drinks, right? You could focus on all kinds of niches and you reach out to people within the same pockets. “You can speak to them the same without having to customize everything.” So I think personalization does not necessarily equal customization you have to do by hand every time. If it can feel the closer to home that it feels, the more your prospect is like, Oh, this is meant for me. So different layers of this, like layer one is I reach out and I say, Hey, we're working with a bunch of law firms.
In Segmentation
What is the thing that I can speak to here that's not some ROI claim, nothing like that. Something that really articulates their current state in a problem they might be experiencing. Subject line is value and social proof. I don't think that we share this stat specifically, but social proof does increase reply rates by 44%. “So I need to pick a logo or two if I can that we work with that's similar.” And then I need to articulate here, here's how our peer solved this problem, or here's what you can do. Here's the outcome that we can get you, et cetera. And then last but not least, my CTA. I need to tell them specifically that if this resonates, here's what they should do.
personalization, and interest. Length. You want to keep your cold emails short, between 50 and 100 words, three to four sentences only following that reply method that Jason just took us through. The language, the words that you use in your cold email should be light on pitch and product “talk, and instead they should lean on priorities, problems, and social proof.” You want to be selling them on what they're already sold on. They're known or inferred priorities based upon what you know about that space. When it comes to personalization, there were two that were king. We've got our activity-based personalization, and we have our company-based personalization, and Jason, you shared that if we stack those, they do even better.
talk, and instead they should lean on priorities, problems, and social proof. You want to be selling them on what they're already sold on. They're known or inferred priorities based upon what you know about that space. When it comes to personalization, there were two that were king. “We've got our activity-based personalization, and we have our company-based personalization,” and Jason, you shared that if we stack those, they do even better. And then we also talked about, this was a huge one. Today's show is brought to you by ConsenSys, which helps your demo keep selling even when you're not in the room. Before I show a demo, I set it up like it might have to work without me. I include these three slides before I drop in.
And then we cover the reply method. That was one boring, short subject line. Two, I need a strong reason that shows them I'm reaching out to you on purpose. It's something about them that they could not mistake for someone else. Third is the problem. I need to agitate a bit and talk about something that is not ideal in their day to day. “Social proof and value.” Here's who we help. Here's an outcome that we help them experience. And then our CTAs, like we talked about, interest-based CTAs, offers, and I need to keep all of that under 75 hordes. If you liked what we shared today, we have a lot of free shit that we put together for you. One, there's a cold email data report.